Witch-king, Bringer of Ruin

—

6cmc 5/3 flying legendary wraith that forces the defending player to sacrifice their weakest creature on every attack — a repeatable edict stapled to an evasive clock. Solid in midrange and control as a persistent threat that strips small utility creatures; fits aristocrats shells by fueling graveyard synergies via forced sacrifices. Tokens-go-wide is a mild negative because the edict always takes the smallest creature (often a token), which lets token decks sacrifice chaff freely, protecting real threats. The trigger is opponent-controlled in the sense that they pick the "least power" creature among ties, and the card does nothing until it attacks.

• The edict trigger sacrifices the creature with the LEAST power — not the defending player's choice. In token-heavy boards the opponent feeds it a 0/1 or 1/1 token, so its disruption is far weaker against go-wide strategies than it appears.

  tagging · claude-sonnet-4-6

• Because the sacrifice happens on attack (not on damage), blockers are chosen before the edict resolves; the defending player cannot block and then sacrifice the blocker to dodge combat damage — they sacrifice before blockers are declared? No: triggers on attack, so it resolves at the beginning of combat on your turn. The forced sacrifice occurs before blockers, so the defending player loses a creature AND must still block if they wish.

  tagging · claude-sonnet-4-6

• At 5/3 flying for 6 mana Witch-king is on-rate but not above it; in Commander he competes with higher-ceiling 6-drops, keeping him tier-2 rather than tier-1.

  tagging · claude-sonnet-4-6

• EDHREC rank: #7,407